• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar

McGhan Law

Legal Help in Southeast Georgia and Northeast Florida

Schedule a Consultation

Or call us at: 912.576.3640

  • Home
  • Welcome
  • Practice Areas
    • Contract Law
      • Wedding and Event Planning Law
    • Criminal Law
      • DUI Defense
      • Florida Sealing or Expungement
      • Georgia Expungement/Record Restriction
    • Divorce and Family Law
      • Child Custody
      • Child Support
      • Uniform Child Custody Jurisdiction and Enforcement Act
    • Employment Law
    • Personal Injury Law
      • Workers’ Compensation
    • Mediation
  • Contact
  • Blawg
  • Payments
    • Invoice Payment
    • Trust Payment
  • Search this Website

Freedom of Speech and the Government Worker

September 28, 2017 by Jennifer McGhan

Speech Involving Public Concerns

If you are a local, state, or federal employee, both the First Amendment Fourteenth Amendments protect you from retaliation for exercising free speech in some employment-related situations. This means that when you exercise your right to free speech, your government employer generally cannot retaliate against you with negative employment action.

The U.S. Supreme Court, in Pickering v. Board of Education, set the rule that public employee speech involving matters of public concern is protected speech under the First Amendment. In determining whether the speech involves matters of public concern, the court created a balancing test:

The interests of the employee as a citizen, in commenting on matters of public concern must be balanced against the interest of the State as an employer, in promoting the efficiency of the public services it performs through its employees.

What this means for all of my public employee readers is that you can speak out at the workplace or at public meetings so long as what you say is a matter of public concern. And that the content of your statement is more important than your public employer’s interest in having an efficient workplace.

This protection is afforded to public employees because public employees are often in the best position to learn the deficiencies in the government agencies for which they work and it is important to allow government employees to make these deficiencies known to the public, so the community can debate how to improve them.

Speech Involving Private Concerns

Things get tricky when the public employee must determine whether the speech is a matter of public concern or an issue related to employment. When speaking, a public employee must speak as a citizen, not as an employee. And further, the subject of the speech must be a matter of public concern, not a personal one.

The Eleventh Circuit recently determined, in Alves v. Board of Regents, that a group of public employees who had been terminated after submitting a memorandum to supervisors alleging leadership and management issues leading to deficiencies in management was not protected speech under the First Amendment.

The Court held that the memorandum concerned the employees’ regular job duties and their ability to fulfill those job duties, and as a result, the employees were speaking as employees, and not as citizens. If the speech takes the form of a private employee grievance about a superior’s management and leadership, it is probably not protected under the First Amendment.

Flow Chart for Government Employee First Amendment Rights

Filed Under: Employment Law Tagged With: employee rights, First Amendment, free speech, freedom of speech, government employee, government worker, workplace

Primary Sidebar

Do You Have a Case?

The legal system can intimidate and overwhlem anyone. We’re here to help find the answers and solutions you need!

SCHEDULE YOUR INITIAL CASE EVALUATION

Call (912) 576-3640 or make an appointment online!

Recent Posts

  • Freedom of Speech and the Government Worker
  • A Step-by-Step Guide to Florida’s Uniform Child Custody Jurisdiction and Enforcement Act
  • Nursing Mothers and the Workplace

Categories

  • Employment Law
  • Family Law

Areas of Practice

  • Contract Law
    • Wedding and Event Planning Law
  • Criminal Law
    • DUI Defense
    • Florida Sealing or Expungement
    • Georgia Expungement/Record Restriction
  • Divorce and Family Law
    • Child Custody
    • Child Support
    • Uniform Child Custody Jurisdiction and Enforcement Act
  • Employment Law
  • Personal Injury Law
    • Workers’ Compensation
  • Mediation

Schedule a Case Evaluation

The legal system can intimidate and overwhelm anyone. We’re here to help find the answers and solutions you need!

SCHEDULE ONLINE
BACK TO TOP
Jennifer L. McGhan website logo

Jennifer L. McGhan, Esq.

575 E. KING AVENUE
KINGSLAND, GA 31548
(912) 576-3640
INFO@MCGHANLAW.COM

Like us on Facebook Follow us on Instagram Follow us on Twitter

DISCLAIMER NOTICE: This web site is an advertisement designed for general information only. The information presented at this site should not be construed to be formal legal advice nor does it form an attorney/client relationship.

© 2023 JENNIFER L. MCGHAN, ESQ.

  • Invoice Payment
  • Trust Payment
  • Terms of Use
  • Privacy Policy